
November 7th
Generation IV
Pokemon Platinum is, without a doubt, the game which I have the strongest childhood memories of. I have vivid recollections of Barry slamming into me running out his house, of Cyrus at Lake Verity, and of Looker generally a weird fucking dude. Over the last month, I got to re-experience the game with my friends, and I undertook the gratifying (and at times extremely arduous) task of completing a (mostly) legitimate living dex. Playing through the game almost 13 years after I first experienced it on my Cobalt DS Lite, I had a wave of recollections and things I wanted to talk about, so join me on this journey, and let me share with you why Sinnoh is so special to me.
We're going to start things off by wandering through the world in roughly gameplay order, where I'll be talking about the things that both brought me joy and surprise. My first note is actually for the very first location in the game, Twinleaf Town. Now, with the knowledge and resources of an adult, I know that Sinnoh as a whole was largely based on Hokkaido, Japan. But when I was a child, and I wasn't so much online as I was sitting on my couch in my old living room which I only have hazy memories of, the snow, the more western architecture compared to HGSS, and the large, sprawling cities all reminded me of my home in British Columbia, Canada.
Twinleaf's melting snow, it's greenish teal grass, and the presence of the three great lakes, the first of which is just out the door, all reminded me of my country, and that resulted in a feeling of familiarity that I never quite got with the other Pokemon games, even Black & White, which was based on a region much geographically closer to me. Looking back to my hazy childhood memories, I projected the snow out into a lot more locations than it's actually in. I vividly remember the melting-snow effect in many locations, but on a replay, I found it only exists in Twinleaf and the routes directly surrounding it! Route 216 and 217, the obligatory snowy hailstorm routes, felt massive in my mind. If you had asked me before my replay how big those areas were, I'd probably have said they occupied a quarter of the game.
That's not to say that all of my memories of Platinum involve the only snowy locations on the map. Out of the landmarks in the game, I have similarly vivid recollections of Jubilife, Canalave, Sunyshore, and most of all, Eterna City. Walking along route 201, I had honestly forgotten that Sandgem Town stood between me and Jubilife. It serves a large narrative purpose, being the location where Professor Rowan's Lab is, and where you first get your Pokedex, but after that event has passed, there's very little reason to ever return, unless you feel like taking a trip to the Pal Park or checking what route the postgame hordes are at that day. When I was child, I think I took the difference in ecology for granted, but playing back through it, it's really odd that Twinleaf just down the road has still unmelted snow, but at Sandgem there are wide, sandy beaches banking an ocean apparently warm enough that children are splashing around in it with tubes all day.
Looking at Sandgem now, I can't help but impulsively think that a rocky beach would suit it better, as those are what I'm most familiar with around the oceans where I live, and it makes me wonder if Pokemon has ever had a rock beach? I can't think of a game that does. Sure, they're less comfortable to walk on, and you can't just set up a towel and lie on them, but they have a beauty of their own, and it would be cool to see something like that in a game. Wind and Waves maybe? Hint hint?
Getting to Jubilife was a rush of excitement. It being the first real "City" of the game, despite not having a Gym as nearly every other landmark with that suffix does, brings with it a whole new tonal palette. Platinum excells, in my opinion, at creating City-style landmarks that feel populated and lived in, despite not being much bigger than past generation towns which feel more like quaint villages. The mixture of concrete floors, condominiums, and large, uninteractable multistory buildings dotted about makes them feel grand, and it was blissfully easy to slip into the fantasy of their scale when I was young, something which I think the modern Pokemon games do extremely poorly.
I don't think I ever figured out what the Global Trade Station did, now that I think of it. This session, I was thankfully able to use it to dodge hundreds of days of honey-tree checking to get Munchlax and his older bro, but when I was kid, I'm not even sure if I returned to it after being told I needed a Gym Badge first. Ironically, if I had, I don't even think I would've gotten anywhere, as at that time, despite having Wifi in the house, I had no idea how to hook my DS up to it, and my parents were just as clueless. We ended up getting it set up near the very end of my Platinum playthrough, which I only know because I actually managed to get Rotom from the Mystery Gift at the time, but I don't think I once did an online trade, or even stepped foot in the basement of the Pokemon Center.
It was on my way to Oreburgh that I caught my very first Party Member, Sparky! I've always had a soft spot for Shinx and its evolutions. I love all canid pokemon but he's just such a cute little guy. It's probably because he's blue. Blue is good color. I think I had a Shinx in my childhood playthrough, but to be honest all I remember about my team in that game was that by the time I was at the Elite Four my Empoleon was Level 100, because I literally used him and nobody else. I chose Piplup again when playing through this month, but poor Bipbup didn't end up on my final team. Sorry buddy, Buizel is just too cute.
Once I got there, Oreburgh was a pretty simple affair. Enter the mines, get Roark to battle me, win because I chose the water starter. But also, this first gym taught me something that I'd let the years let me forget. This game is hard. I was not prepared for the challenge the first Gym leader would pose coming from Sword and Shield. Even having a type effective starter, I still needed to level up my party and get a second decent fighter, which is how I got my third member of my party at the time, Kazza!
Kazza is a traded Abra you can get from an NPC in Oreburgh for giving them a Machop. I'd never had a Psychic type on my party, so kept him around for awhile, even up to the 5th Gym. Eventually he ended up boxed as I replaced him with a Scyther, and later a Garchomp, but for a while he was the powerhouse of my team. He ended up ridiculously overleveled as I first grinded him to 16 so that he could get his first damaging move, then failed to get that move because he fainted on the same encounter where he levelled up (ugh), and then had to grind him to 24 to get his next damaging move. That was not fun. But it did make him a very strong boi.
I'd also like take this time to describe the challenge rules I'd imposed upon myself, in case anyone else would like to suffer through the same set of circumstances as I did. The rules first arose while I was playing Sword and Shield, where, for the most part, I was able to sweep every route with zero challenge or grinding, simply by walking in and pressing A. Near the end of the game, I got pretty tired of how unengaging the gameplay was, and I decided to try imposing a few rules on myself for the remaining few routes. These rules ended up making the game so fun that I felt like kicking myself for not using them the entire game. Going into Platinum, I knew I was going to impose them on myself for the entire playthrough, and oh god, was I not prepared for the ramifications of that fact.
Objective: Make the gameplay of Pokemon more engaging by increasing the challenge on routes, without imposing extreme difficulty or sad vibes through permadeath, like with a Nuzlocke.
Rule 1: When traversing a route which you have not yet through completely, you MAY NOT restore HP in or out of battle via any non-move means. That includes Potions, Milk/other one off healing items, AND backtracking to Pokemon Centers. If you white-out and are automatically healed, that's fine, but it should feel bad. You may count that as a negative point, if you want to keep score. You may use items as normal when returning to already completed routes. This rule does not apply in Dungeons / Gyms / The Elite Four, and you may use on-route healing spots like random cabins with beds in them.
Rule 2: No using healing or status restoration items in combat. You may use Ethers/PP Restoration items, if necessary. Using a healing item in battle counts as a negative point, if you want to keep score. This rule is waived for the Elite Four, as they have Full Restores out the ass and it's only fair.
As I mentioned, I designed these rules in the modern Pokemon games to address what I felt was a lack of challenge, and I had forgotten just how much that challenge wasn't lacking in the old games. I accumulated QUITE A FEW negative points from deaths on the later routes, and the addendum that dungeons are exempt from the rules was added halfway through after dying in turnback cave like three times. I wanted a Gible, damnit!
Regardless, playing through the game with the added restrictions added so much tension and excitement to the experience. I know the whole "if you fail, just feel a bit sad" lack of consquences won't resonate with everyone, and if it doesn't with you, that's fine, play a Nuzlocke or something. But for me, aiming for something and failing is enough of a punishment, and aiming for it and succeeding is a lovely extra boost. Scraping through most of the routes with a nearly entirely fainted party and just making it to the next town was always a great feeling, it brought a sense of antagonism to the level design, that made the journey feel more like a journey.
Before returning to the play-by-play, I want to take a brief interlude as we enter Floaroma town to talk about the gimmicks. The side bullshit. The mechanics they add every generation to keep you coming back to the old routes in hopes of finding some ridiculously rare stupidthingthatwastesDAYSOFYOURLIFEANDOHMYGOD--
Okay, let's reel it in. I don't actually hate most of the Pokemon side gimmicks, and if I'm being honest, I actually find the attempt at giving routes replayability, especially once you get fly and are mostly zipping from POI to POI without touching the ground, an admirable goal. I just think that most of the gimmicks in most Pokemon games fall into one of two categories: Not worth the time, or Necessary if you want to complete the game, and extremely tedious.
I've throught through the mechanics in my head, and I've identified what I feel are five side activities that Platinum wants you to engage with, and I'd like to talk a little about them.
Berries are not original to Gen 4. But there are absolutely fucking everywhere. Floaroma is where you get your Sprayduck (adorable name), and your first berries, which gives you the ability to collect and replant all sorts of berry tries across Sinnoh. Planting spots are sparse, and berries take real life hours to grow, so the game clearly wants you to plant your berries all across the world, and then return to them over the following days to water them, creating a little loop of Sinnoh that you follow as you take care of your plants.
In theory, this is actually pretty cool, but it falls pretty far into the first category of gimmick which I outlined above. The early game berries aren't that good. Status healers are definitely the most useful, as you don't have to waste a turn using an Antidote during combat, but needing to know beforehand what berry to give your Pokemon makes it extremely hard to use to good effect. Oran berries are a simple, uncontroversial hold-item, which I had hoped to be a useful loophole in my challenge rules, but 10 HP is honestly really weak, even as early in the game as Floaroma, and pretty soon after Eterna City you'll already be grappling with deciding which of the much-stronger permanent held items you want each of your party members to be holding, which renders berries almost entirely obsolete. (Honestly, I feel like Berries/Pokemon-usable Consumables should just have a separate hold slot, that would make them much more viable.)
Once giving them to Pokemon isn't useful anymore and you're not strapped enough for cash to cycle through all 30 of your berries to figure out which one heals Paralysis instead of just buying Lava Cookies, the only remaining use for berries is making Poffins. And I'm gonna be real, unless you really like making Poffins, there is NO reason to make them. The Veilstone Department Store sells almost max-level poffins for 6400 Pokedollars, which you can farm in a single match against one of the higher-level trainers with an amulet coin, you can easily max out two or more contest stats on a Pokemon without filling out your sheen, and you don't have to do that stupid touchscreen spinning minigame eight HUNDRED times. Sorry berries, I wanted to love you, but I just can't.
I actually think Honey Trees are really cute, and Platinum solves most of the pain of getting the honey by letting you buy it 10 at a time (compared to Diamond and Pearl where you have to go through the old man's entire dialogue tree to buy one, yikes), and you get to encounter unique Pokemon that you can't get anywhere else in the game. To a casual player, that's actually really cool. No notes.
The problem, my dear readers, comes from Munchlax. Munchlax, munchlax, munchlax, MUNCHLAX! If you want to get a living dex like I did and you don't lucky with a GTS trade, prepare for absolute agony. People often say that Munchlax has a 1% chance of spawning. Which is true. Technically. But the reality is so. much. worse. Let's go over it.
First of all, Munchlax can only spawn in 4 of the 21 total honey trees throughout the game. Two are determined by your Trainer ID, and two are determined by your Secret ID. You CANNOT find your Secret ID without hacking tools, and when Platinum came out, nobody knew how to convert the Trainer ID into the lucky trees. That means, if you're playing the game just as a normal person trying to get Munchlax, your odds go down to [1/524](4/21 * 1/100), ASSUMING you're evenly distributing honey across every tree in the game. Which, let's not forget, many of those trees are in hard-to-reach/lategame locations, so this will not always be possible.
These trees also have a 9% chance to not spawn any Pokemon, by the way, just to add insult to injury, and they take 6 HOURS to roll their Pokemon. And if you leave them for more than 24 hours, the encounter is lost.
Okay, so lets say that you use the calculator and know your two guaranteed lucky trees. If you're me, you'll decide screw it, I'm not going to put honey on every tree in Sinnoh, I'm just going to put it on these two trees on repeat until I get a lucky roll. The honey trees do not like this discrimination. In fact, they have one final fuck-you. We'll skip the complicated math because the spawn groups for the honey trees are honestly needlessly complicated, but the important fact is that Munchlax exists in a group of its own. Every other possible spawn group cannot spawn a Munchlax. If you slather honey on the same tree twice in a row, it has a 90% chance to reroll the encounter from the same group, meaning if you didn't get Munchlax last time, you have a 90% chance ON TOP of the 1/524 odds to not get it AGAIN.
So, lets say you zig zag each day, slathering honey on tree A, moving to tree B and slathering, then closing the game. Then you come back, check the encounter on tree B, re-apply honey to it, check the encounter on tree A, re-apply honey on it, then close the game. You just dropped the odds of one of your two trees from 1/524 to [1/5250]((1/524)/(100-90))! Which means your actual rate for finding Munchlax on one of those trees in a day is 1/1444. Wonderful. Great.
Genuinely, why did Game Freak think this was a good idea?
Fishing is fine. I don't hate it or anything, but you can only really get interesting encounters with the Super Rod in the postgame, which makes it pretty useless before you get to the Battle Frontier unless you really want to catch a Gyarados. I don't really think it's worth it.
I'm going to change my tune a little bit, because I actually really like the underground. It's pretty light on content when you don't have anyone around to play local multiplayer with, but the mining minigame is fun, and the fact that you can renewably obtain a lot of evolution stones and fossils down there is pretty cool! The orbs system is worthless in the year 2026 though, as the only way you can remove rocks from your secret base is by winning flags through local multiplayer fights, which is extremely annoying to do now. Fun fact, did you know that Spiritomb can only be encountered after encountering 32 different players in the underground? NPCs don't count. That really sucks.
Contests are actually pretty fun to play, at least the first few times, but they really don't give you anything of value, which is unfortunate given the amount of effort the game invests in its systems. The only real value from the contests are winning ribbons to get into the Ribbon Syndicate in the postgame, but that's trivalized by the woman who wants you to be her [sidepiece](This is canon to me, you can't tell me otherwise) in Sunyshore, so I honestly just ended up chatting with her instead. I wish Game Freak would invest more energy into giving meaningful rewards for engaging with their side systems. It would've been a lot of fun if you could earn max revives or vitamins for performing well here.
Side-tangent over, lets get back to the main journey. Honestly, at this point my thoughts get pretty sparse. I absolutely adore the vibes of Eterna Forest and City, but I don't have much to say about them other than the fact that they fill me with warm fuzzies and feel like home.
I caught my Buizel at Valley Windworks which marked the end of Bipbup in my party, which was unexpected. I thought I would've kept Piplup in my party the whole way through for nostalgia reason, but honestly I love that stupid otter little guy. After getting the Bike from Eterna, I went down Cycling Road and got my 3rd and 4th party members--a Ponyta to fill the Fire-type niche, and a Gible, since I'd never had a Dragon type on my party either. At some point on the road to Hearthhome, my Togepi hatched, and Boykisser joined the team. And finally, after much goading, a friend convinced me to go back to Eterna Forest and get a Buneary to name after her and use as an HM Slave. The HM Slave part didn't last for long--my challenge rules basically mandated that all of my Pokemon be at least semi-competent fighters, so I ended up distributing the HM moves across my whole team. But the Buneary stayed, marking the completion of my endgame party.
Solaceon town was where I finally engaged with Ball Capsules as a mechanic, mostly because I realized you show the Unown for each letter to a child in the town and write horrible things that display when your Pokemon is called out. Genuinely one of the best mechanics in this generation, I had so much fun decorating each of my main team's balls, and it's really sad that they dropped the system in Gen V. This is also where I found out BDSP removed the letter seals. I can't say I'm surprised, but I can say I'm devastated. Then again, I'm devastated by most of BDSP, which is why I'm playing this and not that. This little side-feature is why I have a box of every Unown in the game!
The routes following Solaceon were the hardest for me to complete with my challenge rules. The combination of the constant rain and my not-very-optimized team for taking out the trainers along the way resulted in multiple white-outs, but eventually I limped my way over to Veilstone, and things started looking up from there.
Veilstone was a fun distraction, and at this point in my journey I'd racked up quite a few Pokedollars from not spending them on healing items or revives. So my team got a well-deserved power boost after buying all the vitamins they could ask for at the department store, which may have slightly messed up the local economy. Imagine being a small business owner and some 10-year old comes in with $300,000 to buy out your entire stock. Yes, I KNOW Pokedollars are Yen let me fantasize okay?
Sweeping through the route from Veilstone to Pastoria was easy, but Wake served as a pretty big boulder in my path which required me to grind a bit to get my Pokemon up to snuff. Is it weird that I didn't remember Pastoria even existed? I guess it's probably because, as far as uniqueness goes, Pastoria has nothing going for it. It's just a bunch of houses in the grass, and it doesn't even have a bunch of flowers like Floaroma. Really weird City, it just feels like filler. After I managed to crash through Wake, wrapping back around to Hearthome was a nice victory lap. It's a pain how overleveled the Gym leaders are in this Gen, but the power rush you get entering a new route after beating them? It almost makes it worth it.
Of course, at this point I had to deal with Team Galactic calling in bomb threats, but if you wanted a plot recap, you could go watch a Let's Play. Can I just say, though, that Cyrus is kinda awesome? Like, he doesn't want to do harm anyone meaninglessly (uh, except erase them from existence I guess, that's not great), and his dialogue and goals are genuinely pretty intimidating. I really like him as a Team Leader, he has spooky energy.
Making it to Canalave felt really monumentous for me. I hadn't realized how late-game it was, and the combination of getting Surf from Wake and crossing the sea to Iron Island was both a rush of freedom and a blast from the past. It's been too long to remember why, but I have strong memories of spending hours and hours wandering around Canalave's dock as a kid. I think I was trying to level up a Psyduck for some reason? But I don't know why I'd be spending time in a town, in that case. Either way, hearing the music kick in and walking across the big drawbridge was super nostalgic. I picked up Riley's Riolu egg at Iron Island, got the shiny stone to level up my Togetic into a Togekiss, and from there, I headed to Snowpoint.
Snowpoint's gym was fun, but for the most part, my memories of this part of the game actually focus on my real life at the time. Things were going pretty poorly with the project I was working on for work, and I was feeling really down, and my Mom, who lives in a different city, came to visit me for my birthday. We went on a few hikes, she got to have a real conversation with my partner for the first time, and it honestly helped my mental state a lot more than I thought it would. It's easy to forget how reassuring talking to a parent can be. I beat the Snowpoint Gym while sitting on the couch with her, bitching about the ice puzzle at the same time as we were hashing out issues I was having in my life. Thanks, mom!
This BOAT, though. What a tease. I lied a little at the beginning of this article. Yes, I have strong memories of Canalave, Eterna, Jubilife, and Sunyshore, but by far the strongest memories I have from Pokemon platinum are from the Resort Zone. I'll talk about in more detail when we get there, but seeing this stupid boat and knowing that's where it would take me, but that I haven't the right to get there yet drove me up the wall, and really pushed me through to completing the main campaign.
And, to be fair, I was pretty close to doing just that. After getting the Icicle Badge from Candice, I returned to Veilstone and finally got to take the path to Sunyshore. The city whose route is visible after the Fourth Gym, but isn't reachable until after the 7th. Because of a power outage. In the city whose FLOORS ARE SOLAR PANELS. But I got there, and at this point the Gyms were starting to feel more like an obstacle than a challenge, which was [reassurance](FALSE reassurance) for the final battle yet to come. Sunyshore is also where you get the non-letter ball capsule seals. The selection rotates each day, and they have a lot of fun ones. It's a shame you can only get here 7/8ths through the campaign, but if you're interested in kitting out your Pokeballs, definitely give it a visit.
Obtaining Waterfall and swimming up the cascade to Victory Road's entrance was momentous. Say what you will about requiring a second HM move on your Surf user for all of the five waterfalls in the game, but being able to summit previously impossible barriers is empowering. The move also excellent power, which takes the edge off a bit. I'd forgotten that you could hear the Pokemon League theme from the entrance to Victory Road. It's such a strangely somber song, as though self aware that your journey is nearing an end, and hearing it before even stepping foot into victory road was a treat.
The road itself was a lot of fun, and the first time I actually felt the need to use Repels, mostly because of those fuckass Gravellers that use Explode on their first turn, but the area is also just massive, and encountering every wild Pokemon along the way brings you to snail's crawl. There's enough trainers in the route to level you up without them adding onto it.
And there it was, I was at the doors to the castle. A few steps forwards, and I'd be fighting the ultimate challenge of the game. But it wasn't quite time yet. At this point, I'd progressed quite far in front of my friends, and I wanted to at least attempt to wait for them before going and beating the game. So I shot off on my Togekiss and went out to all the old routes to fill out my Living Dex. Wait, did I mention that I was doing a--
Yeah, I decided to go for a Living Dex! As I've probably made self-evident, I'm not a big fan of the traditional Pokemon challenge runs. No shade to anyone who likes Nuzlocks and the like, but the whole punishment of death thing doesn't really do it for me. I like my funny guys, I want to keep them!
But I also love these games, and yearn for a way to get more out of them. The first time I went for a Living Dex was in Pokemon Sword and Shield (which was also the last game I played before this one, almost six years ago). I made it pretty far, but I got burnt out when I realized that I honestly didn't care for the game that much. I lost those boxes when I sold my Switch for a Switch OLED. Thanks for the no cloud saves, Game Freak!
For this game, my beloved Sinnoh, I knew I wanted to do it for real this time. I think when I played Sword and Shield I was going for a national living dex (or at least as much of the national dex you can obtain post Dexxit), but this time I decided to constrain myself just to the regional dex. My hope is that over the next several months I'll replay all of the old Pokemon games, and through those, I'll accumulate a national living dex naturally, but we'll see how that goes. But even the comparably simple goal of getting a regional living dex proved to be a much more involved challenge than I had initially presumed.
Throughout my adventures up to the Pokemon League, I'd been making a point of catching new Pokemon I encountered, but I was by no means being a completionist, and there were loads of Pokemon on the routes I had already traversed that I hadn't even seen. That was the easy part. The much, much more time consuming part was evolving all those Pokemon, in many cases multiple times so that I could have their midlevel evolution and their final one in my box. Tell me, for god's sake, why are there so many friendship evolutions? They're literally the most time consuming thing and I had to do them like a dozen times! That includes Buneary twice, since I had Jessica on my party, and didn't want blank spaces in my boxes. And if you recall, Buneary gets caught at Friendship ZERO, not 70 like the rest of them.
I managed to get most of the Pokemon legitimately, only cheating in ones which were impossible to obtain, even with trading with my friends on Platinum. I probably could have GTS'd some of them, but I'm not too worried about it. I'm pretty sure I'll have a chance to catch the ones that were cheated legitimately in the other gens before finishing my national living dex in Sun and Moon.
Filling out these boxes was an incredible, and sometimes frustrating ordeal, but all in all it was very fulfilling. Poor Yoshi gained 31 levels in the Daycare from all the eggs they were laying. To enshrine the accomplishment, I created an interactive box viewer where you can see all my Pokemon! The ones with colored backgrounds have special notes by me on them, give it a perusal.
Red highlights indicate illegitimate Pokémon, blue highlights indicate a creature of interest. Click to read my notes.
It took me until the postgame, but I'm proud to say I did it. Not only did I get all of the regional Pokemon, but also all of the alternate forms, and the event legendaries! Yes, it was a long journey, but I'd definitely do it again (and I plan to in HGSS!)
But enough dilly-dallying, it's time to face the Elite Four!
Holy shit, the Elite Four. I was not prepared for them. Most of my team was level 49 and 50 when I first walked in, which is significantly lower than their baseline of around 57, and that's not even counting Cynthia who's well into the 60s! But, I did have an ace up my sleeve. Right from the start, I knew I wasn't going to limit myself to not using healing items in the Elite Four. It wouldn't be fair anyways, they love spamming Full Restores. So for the first time in the entire game, I got to go all out with battle items, and god, I needed it.
Fighting the Elite Four underleveled was a grueling endeavour, and I'm only slightly ashamed to say that I had to use a couple savestates near the end, but we did it. My team and I smashed through Aaron, Bertha, Flint, and Lucian, and after what felt like an age (and perhaps was with how slow Platinum's health bars move), we were standing before the champion of Sinnoh.
Cynthia.
Thanks for reminiscing with me, here's a little gift!
P.S. It persists across page loads ;)